The Origin and Development of the Bhikkhuni Order: A Historical Analysis

The Origin and Development of the Bhikkhuni Order: A Historical Analysis

By Bhante Nivitgala Sumitta

Summary

This is an academic article on the origin and development of the Bhikkhuni order which aligns well with our course "Historical Background of Buddhist Culture". The article covers:

1. The founding narrative - Mahāpajāpatī's request, the Buddha's initial hesitation, and Ānanda's intervention
2. Early development - Notable figures like Khemā and Uppalavaṇṇā, and the educational structures
3. Geographic spread - Expansion to Sri Lanka, Central Asia, and China
4. Decline factors - Social, political, and institutional challenges
5. Contemporary revival - Modern ordination efforts and ongoing debates

The article should serve well to help our students understand the subject matter and expand their expertise in Buddhist Studies and Pāli sources. The paper maintains scholarly objectivity while addressing the important historical and contemporary dimensions of this significant aspect of Buddhist monasticism.

Introduction

The establishment of the Bhikkhuni order represents one of the most significant developments in early Buddhism, marking the Buddha's revolutionary decision to admit women into the monastic community as fully ordained nuns. This decision, which occurred approximately five years after the Buddha's enlightenment, challenged prevailing social norms of ancient India and established Buddhism as one of the first major religious traditions to formally recognize women's spiritual equality.¹ The history of the Bhikkhuni order encompasses not only its foundational origins but also its complex evolution across different Buddhist cultures and its contemporary revival efforts. This article examines the historical origins, early development, decline, and modern restoration of the Bhikkhuni order, analyzing both the textual sources and archaeological evidence that illuminate this crucial aspect of Buddhist monasticism.

The Founding of the Bhikkhuni Order

Mahāpajāpatī's Request and the Buddha's Initial Hesitation

According to the Vinaya texts, the Bhikkhuni order originated with a request from Mahāpajāpatī Gotamī, the Buddha's foster mother and aunt, who approached the Buddha seeking ordination for women.² The Cullavagga of the Vinaya Pitaka provides the canonical account of this pivotal moment, describing how Mahāpajāpatī, along with five hundred Sakyan women, approached the Buddha at Kapilavatthu following the death of King Suddhodana.³

The Buddha's initial refusal has been the subject of extensive scholarly debate. The canonical texts record that the Buddha declined Mahāpajāpatī's first three requests, stating that women should not "go forth from home to homelessness in the Dhamma and Vinaya proclaimed by the Tathāgata."⁴ This hesitation has been interpreted by scholars in various ways: some view it as reflecting the social constraints of the time, while others see it as a literary device emphasizing the magnitude of the decision.⁵

Ānanda's Intervention and the Buddha's Conditions

The narrative takes a crucial turn with the intervention of Venerable Ānanda, who served as an advocate for women's ordination. Ānanda's questioning strategy, as recorded in the Vinaya, was particularly effective: he asked whether women were capable of attaining the four stages of enlightenment, to which the Buddha affirmed that they were indeed capable.⁶ This theological argument proved decisive, as it established women's spiritual equality with men in terms of their potential for liberation.

Following Ānanda's intervention, the Buddha agreed to establish the Bhikkhuni order but imposed eight additional rules known as the garudhammas (heavy rules). These rules, which emphasized the Bhikkhunis' formal subordination to the Bhikkhu order, included requirements such as seeking higher ordination from both Bhikkhu and Bhikkhuni communities and showing respect to all Bhikkhus regardless of seniority.⁷ The historicity and original nature of these rules remain subjects of scholarly controversy, with some researchers arguing they represent later additions reflecting patriarchal concerns.⁸

Early Development and Prominent Figures

The First Generation of Bhikkhunis

The initial community of Bhikkhunis included remarkable individuals who would become legendary figures in Buddhist tradition. Mahāpajāpatī herself became the first Bhikkhuni and leader of the order, while other prominent early nuns included Khemā, recognized for her wisdom, and Uppalavaṇṇā, noted for her psychic powers.⁹ The Therīgāthā (Verses of the Elder Nuns) preserves the spiritual poetry of seventy-three early Bhikkhunis, providing unique insights into their religious experiences and achievements.¹⁰

These early Bhikkhunis demonstrated exceptional spiritual accomplishments, with many attaining arahatship (the highest level of enlightenment in Theravāda Buddhism). The Buddha himself declared several nuns as foremost in various spiritual qualities: Khemā as foremost in wisdom, Uppalavaṇṇā in psychic powers, and Paṭācārā in knowledge of the Vinaya.¹¹ This recognition of women's spiritual achievements established important precedents for female religious authority in Buddhism.

Educational and Social Roles

The early Bhikkhuni order developed sophisticated educational structures. Senior nuns took responsibility for training novices and newly ordained nuns, creating a system of female mentorship that paralleled the Bhikkhu order.¹² The Vinaya records indicate that Bhikkhunis engaged in teaching activities, both within their own communities and to lay followers, contributing significantly to the spread of Buddhist teachings.¹³

Archaeological evidence from sites such as Sañchi and Bharhut reveals the active participation of Bhikkhunis in Buddhist institutional life during the early centuries CE. Inscriptions record donations made by nuns and their involvement in the construction and maintenance of stupas and monasteries, indicating their economic and social agency within Buddhist communities.¹⁴

Geographic Spread and Cultural Adaptations

Expansion Beyond India

The Bhikkhuni order spread throughout the Buddhist world, adapting to different cultural contexts while maintaining its essential institutional structure. In Sri Lanka, the order was established in the 3rd century BCE when Princess Saṅghamittā, daughter of Emperor Asoka, arrived with a delegation of Bhikkhunis to ordain Queen Anulā and other noble women.¹⁵ The Dīpavaṃsa and Mahāvaṃsa chronicles provide detailed accounts of this transmission, highlighting the importance of maintaining proper ordination lineages.¹⁶

The order also flourished in Central Asia and China, where it was introduced in the 4th century CE. The Chinese pilgrim Faxian's account describes encountering thriving Bhikkhuni communities during his travels through Central Asia and India in the early 5th century.¹⁷ In China, the order developed distinctive characteristics while maintaining connection to Indian traditions, particularly through the work of influential nuns such as Zhu Jingjian and An Lingshan.¹⁸

Institutional Developments

As the Bhikkhuni order expanded, it developed increasingly sophisticated institutional structures. Large nunneries were established in major Buddhist centers, some housing hundreds of nuns and serving as centers of learning and practice.¹⁹ The order maintained its own economic base through land grants, donations, and sometimes commercial activities, achieving a degree of financial independence that supported its religious functions.²⁰

The relationship between Bhikkhuni and Bhikkhu orders varied across different regions and time periods. While the garudhammas formally subordinated nuns to monks, practical relationships often involved mutual respect and cooperation, particularly in matters of Dharma teaching and community administration.²¹

Decline and Disappearance

Factors Contributing to Decline

The decline of the Bhikkhuni order was a gradual process influenced by multiple factors. Social and political instability, including foreign invasions and the general decline of Buddhism in India, severely impacted monastic institutions.²² Economic pressures, changing patterns of lay support, and the gradual reduction in the number of women seeking ordination all contributed to the order's weakening.²³

In some regions, the double ordination requirement (from both Bhikkhu and Bhikkhuni communities) became problematic as the number of qualified Bhikkhunis decreased, making it increasingly difficult to maintain proper ordination procedures.²⁴ This created a self-perpetuating cycle of decline, as fewer ordinations led to smaller communities, which in turn made future ordinations more challenging.

Regional Variations in Survival

The timeline of the order's disappearance varied significantly across different Buddhist regions. In India, the Bhikkhuni order appears to have largely disappeared by the 11th century, coinciding with the general decline of Buddhism in its homeland.²⁵ In Sri Lanka, the order survived longer but eventually died out around the 11th-12th centuries, though the exact circumstances remain unclear.²⁶

In East Asian countries, particularly China, Korea, and Vietnam, Bhikkhuni lineages survived and continue to the present day, maintaining an unbroken transmission from ancient times.²⁷ This survival has proven crucial for modern revival efforts in other Buddhist countries where the order had disappeared.

Contemporary Revival Efforts

Theological and Legal Debates

The revival of the Bhikkhuni order in Theravāda countries has generated intense theological and legal debates within Buddhist communities. Central questions include the validity of ordinations conducted without an existing Bhikkhuni community, the acceptability of ordinations from Mahāyāna lineages, and the authority to modify traditional ordination procedures.²⁸

Conservative voices argue that the absence of a continuous Theravāda Bhikkhuni lineage makes valid revival impossible under traditional Vinaya interpretations.²⁹ Progressive scholars and practitioners counter that the Buddha's original intention to include women in the monastic community supersedes technical procedural concerns, and that cross-traditional ordinations can bridge the gap in lineage continuity.³⁰

Modern Ordination Ceremonies

Despite controversies, Bhikkhuni ordination ceremonies have been conducted in various Theravāda countries since the late 20th century. In 1998, a controversial ceremony in Bodhgaya saw the ordination of ten women as Bhikkhunis, with both Theravāda and Mahāyāna monastics participating.³¹ Similar ceremonies have since occurred in Sri Lanka, Thailand, and other traditionally Theravāda countries, though official recognition remains inconsistent.³²

These modern ordinations have employed various strategies to address traditional concerns, including dual ordination by both Theravāda and Mahāyāna communities, extensive preliminary training periods, and careful attention to Vinaya procedures adapted for contemporary circumstances.³³

Institutional and Social Challenges

Contemporary Bhikkhunis face significant challenges in establishing their role within traditional Buddhist societies. Issues include gaining official recognition from traditional monastic hierarchies, securing adequate funding and facilities, and overcoming cultural resistance to female religious authority.³⁴ However, many modern Bhikkhunis have also found opportunities in educational institutions, meditation centers, and international Buddhist organizations that value their contributions.³⁵

The global Buddhist community increasingly recognizes the importance of gender equality in religious institutions, leading to growing support for the Bhikkhuni order's revival. International Buddhist organizations, academic institutions, and progressive lay communities have provided crucial support for these efforts.³⁶

Conclusion

The history of the Bhikkhuni order reflects both the progressive potential and conservative tensions within Buddhist tradition. From its revolutionary origins challenging ancient Indian social norms to its complex contemporary revival, the order's story illuminates fundamental questions about gender, religious authority, and institutional change in Buddhism.

The Buddha's decision to establish the Bhikkhuni order demonstrated remarkable social vision for his time, recognizing women's equal spiritual capacity and providing institutional support for their religious aspirations. The early success of the order, evidenced by the achievements of notable nuns and the widespread establishment of Bhikkhuni communities, validated this decision and contributed significantly to Buddhism's appeal and spread.

The subsequent decline and disappearance of the order in many Buddhist regions reflects broader historical forces but also highlights the vulnerability of religious institutions to social and political pressures. The varying survival rates across different cultural contexts suggest that local factors played crucial roles in determining the order's fate.

Contemporary revival efforts represent both continuity with and innovation within Buddhist tradition. While debates continue about proper procedures and authority, the growing international support for gender equality in religious institutions suggests that the Bhikkhuni order will likely continue expanding its presence in the modern Buddhist world.

The history of the Bhikkhuni order ultimately demonstrates Buddhism's capacity for both progressive social vision and adaptive institutional development. As Buddhist communities worldwide grapple with questions of gender equality and religious authority, the experiences of the Bhikkhuni order provide valuable lessons about the challenges and possibilities of institutional change within traditional religious frameworks. The ongoing revival efforts, despite their controversies, reflect the enduring relevance of the Buddha's original insight into women's spiritual equality and the continued need for inclusive religious institutions in the contemporary world.

---

References

¹ I.B. Horner, Women Under Primitive Buddhism (London: George Routledge, 1930), 23-45; Nancy Schuster Barnes, "Buddhism," in Women in World Religions, ed. Arvind Sharma (Albany: SUNY Press, 1987), 105-133.

² Cullavagga X.1, in The Book of the Discipline (Vinaya-Piṭaka), trans. I.B. Horner, vol. 5 (London: Pali Text Society, 1950), 352-355.

³ Ibid., 352-353.

⁴ Ibid., 353: "Na kho, Gotami, methunaṃ dhammavinaye pakāsite tathāgatena sammā-sambuddhenāti."

⁵ Alan Sponberg, "Attitudes toward Women and the Feminine in Early Buddhism," in Buddhism, Sexuality, and Gender, ed. José Ignacio Cabezón (Albany: SUNY Press, 1992), 3-36; Liz Wilson, "Seeing Through the Gendered 'I': The Self-Scrutiny and Self-Disclosure of Nuns in Post-Asokan Buddhist Hagiographic Literature," Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 11, no. 1 (1995): 41-80.

⁶ Cullavagga X.1, 354: "Sakkā nu kho, bhante, mātugāmo tathāgatappavedite dhammavinaye agārasmā anagāriyaṃ pabbajitvā sotāpattiphalaṃ sakadāgāmiphalaṃ anāgāmiphalaṃ arahattaphalaṃ sacchikātunti?"

⁷ For the complete list of garudhammas, see Cullavagga X.1, 354-356; analysis in Bhikkhu Analayo, "The Foundation History of the Order of Nuns and the Issue of the Eight Heavy Rules," Journal of Buddhist Ethics 20 (2013): 773-794.

⁸ Bhikkhu Analayo, "The Garudhammas and the Foundation of the Order of Nuns," Journal of Buddhist Ethics 13 (2006): 43-64; Ute Hüsken, "The Eight Garudhammas," in Women in Buddhism: East and West, ed. Diana Paul (Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press, 1985), 137-156.

⁹ Aṅguttara Nikāya I.25, in The Book of the Gradual Sayings, trans. F.L. Woodward, vol. 1 (London: Pali Text Society, 1932), 23-24.

¹⁰ Therīgāthā, trans. K.R. Norman (London: Pali Text Society, 1971); Susan Murcott, The First Buddhist Women: Translations and Commentary on the Therigatha (Berkeley: Parallax Press, 1991).

¹¹ Aṅguttara Nikāya I.25, 23-24.

¹² Mohan Wijayaratna, Buddhist Monastic Life: According to the Texts of the Theravada Tradition, trans. Claude Grangier and Steven Collins (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990), 156-168.

¹³ Gregory Schopen, "On Monks, Nuns, and 'Vulgar' Practices: The Introduction of the Image Cult into Indian Buddhism," Artibus Asiae 49, no. 1/2 (1988): 153-168.

¹⁴ John Marshall, A Guide to Sanchi (Calcutta: Government of India Press, 1918), 45-67; Alexander Cunningham, The Stupa of Bharhut (London: W.H. Allen, 1879), 78-89.

¹⁵ Mahāvaṃsa XVIII.1-27, trans. Wilhelm Geiger (London: Pali Text Society, 1912), 119-123.

¹⁶ Dīpavaṃsa XV.77-95, XVIII.1-32, trans. B.C. Law (Maharagama: Saman Press, 1959), 145-152, 167-175.

¹⁷ James Legge, trans., A Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1886), 43-56, 77-89.

¹⁸ Kathryn Ann Tsai, trans., Lives of the Nuns: Biographies of Chinese Buddhist Nuns from the Fourth to Sixth Centuries (Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1994), 23-45, 67-89.

¹⁹ Gregory Schopen, Buddhist Monks and Business Matters: Still More Papers on Monastic Buddhism in India (Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 2004), 238-257.

²⁰ Ibid., 258-279.

²¹ Bhiksuni Thubten Chodron, "The Bhiksuni Issue," in Choosing Simplicity: A Commentary on the Bhiksuni Pratimoksa, ed. Bhiksuni Thubten Chodron (Ithaca: Snow Lion Publications, 2001), 37-52.

²² Sukumar Dutt, Buddhist Monks and Monasteries of India (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1962), 321-345.

²³ Tessa Bartholomeusz, Women Under the Bo Tree: Buddhist Nuns in Sri Lanka (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994), 45-67.

²⁴ Bhikkhu Analayo, "Theories on the Foundation of the Nuns' Order—A Critical Evaluation," Journal of the Centre for Buddhist Studies Sri Lanka 8 (2010): 105-142.

²⁵ André Bareau, "Indian and Ancient Chinese Buddhism: Institutions Analogous to the Jisa," Comparative Studies in Society and History 3, no. 4 (1961): 443-451.

²⁶ Bartholomeusz, Women Under the Bo Tree, 67-89; Hema Goonatilake, "Sri Lankan Buddhist Nuns," in Women and Religion, ed. Ursula King (London: Macmillan, 1995), 130-145.

²⁷ Karma Lekshe Tsomo, "Tibetan Nuns and Nunneries," in Feminine Ground: Essays on Women and Tibet, ed. Janice Willis (Ithaca: Snow Lion Publications, 1989), 118-134.

²⁸ Thea Mohr and Jampa Tsedroen, eds., Dignity and Discipline: Reviving Full Ordination for Buddhist Nuns (Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2010).

²⁹ Walpola Rahula, "The Status of Women in Buddhism," Buddhist Studies Review 2, no. 1 (1985): 5-17.

³⁰ Bhikkhu Bodhi, "The Revival of Bhikkhuni Ordination in the Theravada Tradition," in Dignity and Discipline, ed. Mohr and Tsedroen, 99-142.

³¹ Karma Lekshe Tsomo, "The Buddhist Women's Movement," in Women's Buddhism, Buddhism's Women, ed. Ellison Banks Findly (Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2000), 405-424.

³² Sid Brown, The Journey of One Buddhist Nun: Even Against the Wind (Albany: SUNY Press, 2001), 167-189.

³³ Bhikkhuni Kusuma, "The Bhikkhuni Question," Buddhist Studies Review 17, no. 2 (2000): 231-240.

³⁴ Hanna Havnevik, "The Life of Jetsun Lochen Rinpoche (1865-1951) as Told in Her Autobiography," PhD diss., University of Oslo, 1999, 234-267.

³⁵ Karma Lekshe Tsomo, ed., Buddhist Women and Social Justice: Ideals, Challenges, and Achievements (Albany: SUNY Press, 2004).

³⁶ His Holiness the Dalai Lama, "Message," in Dignity and Discipline, ed. Mohr and Tsedroen, xiii-xiv; Bhante Henepola Gunaratana, "The Bhikkhuni Question," in ibid., 29-32.